Virtual Desktop Infrastructure (VDI) and Automated Storage Tiering

Over the past couple of years vendors and customers have both figured out that storage for Virtual Desktop Infrastructure (VDI) is a different beast. Hopefully gone are the days where designs call to co-mingle VDI with your other storage needs, unless you are just providing a small amount of desktops. There are a lot of storage options available today and many are specifically marketed to the VDI market. In this article, I’d like to share my thoughts and real world experiences regarding virtual desktop infrastructure, storage types, and performance methods.

My discussion will be generic on purpose. I don’t intend to sway anyone’s decision for or against any particular storage vendor. My aim is to educate people on what they should be considering when purchasing or evaluating storage for virtual desktops.

Planning Virtual Desktop Infrastructure: Storage Types

Classic enterprise storage: These are the big iron types or large enterprise storage arrays that are typically a general purpose type of storage. They might be able to serve up multiple storage protocols such as fiber channel, iSCSI, NFS, and CIFS. They typically would combine group disks into raid groups, and more recently pool disks into similar types and create tiers of disks.

Hybrid storage: This type of storage was introduced within the past couple of years. It offers a mix of flash storage (SSD) and slower SATA disks. But these typically do it in a more modern way than the enterprise arrays are able to do.

Sponsored Content

What is “Inside Microsoft Teams”?

“Inside Microsoft Teams” is a webcast series, now in Season 4 for IT pros hosted by Microsoft Product Manager, Stephen Rose. Stephen & his guests comprised of customers, partners, and real-world experts share best practices of planning, deploying, adopting, managing, and securing Teams. You can watch any episode at your convenience, find resources, blogs, reviews of accessories certified for Teams, bonus clips, and information regarding upcoming live broadcasts. Our next episode, “Polaris Inc., and Microsoft Teams- Reinventing how we work and play” will be airing on Oct. 28th from 10-11am PST.

Flash storage: An all-flash storage array is typically an array that was designed for all flash and thus its operating system was created to take full advantage of the performance characteristics that SSD offers. While you could in theory purchase an enterprise array and only put flash drives in it, this would not be equal to the modern arrays that were designed for flash from the ground up.

Performance Methods

Caching: All of the storage types that I discussed do some method of caching, and some offer more than one in the same array. Some things to think about when it comes to caching: Does the array caching both read and write or is it just read cache? This will help you evaluate how and for what this cache layer might be used. Also, is the cache global or can you turn it on and off for specific LUNs or groups of storage? These are both important things to consider when designing and sizing storage for VDI.

Storage tiering: This typically is found in the classic enterprise storage arrays. It’s the practice of creating pools or raid groups of disks that offer a specific performance option. For example, I might create a pool of 15K fiber channel disks and use this as a performance tier. By doing this I will manually place my workloads here that I want to have this level of performance. Then I might create a capacity tier that is made up of SATA drives. This is not a horrible method, but it requires you to deeply understand your requirements so that you both satisfy the capacity and performance needs of your workload. This also offers level of predictability because you can count on the known performance of a group of disks and not have to reply on the promises of modern storage techniques that can be at times a mystery.

Automated storage tiering: This method can be done very differently between the modern hybrid/all flash arrays vs the enterprise arrays. The idea of auto tiering is that data would be moved between performance tiers depending on if it required more or less performance. Thus giving data that needs performance access to smaller disks that offer high performance while slow workloads could fall down to the large slow performing disks. But the ways that the different storage types do this is very different.

Words of Caution

While I believe that you can successfully design any of the types of storage that I talked about here for VDI, you must fully understand your needs to make sure the storage will deliver and not fail. The needs of VDI can at times be heavy on reads and then be almost all writes. It will also be very spiky in its demand for I/O, meaning that a desktop might be using 15 IOPs one minute, and then a user does something more advanced and requires a few hundred IOPs. So you must be able to design a solution that will both provide you capacity and I/O, but also deal with the fluctuating needs that this type of workload will demand.

To finally get back to the title of this post, I cannot emphasize enough to look at how a storage array will cache and promote data between tiers. Since VDI performance can rapidly change I have seen that you cannot rely on an array that does not make caching or promotion of data in a real-time fashion. This means that if you have to wait minutes or hours for data to be evaluated for promotion to a better performing data tier, you are likely to miss your performance need. This means that your data will be stuck with the tier of disk that it resides on at the time of the increased demand.

This does not mean that the performance will suck, that will all depend on the design and number of disks in the storage. But the promise is often that you can build capacity with slower disks and supplement with fewer fast disks. This works well for many traditional server workloads, but it just does not fly in the VDI world.

To wrap things up, I recommend that you compare your leading option with other offerings, and if you are dealing with a vendor directly, talk to your preferred partner for a sanity check. Also it never hurts to seek feedback from other customers ask for references of similar use cases.

Related Topics:


Don't have a login but want to join the conversation? Sign up for a Petri Account

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

External Sharing and Guest User Access in Microsoft 365 and Teams

This eBook will dive into policy considerations you need to make when creating and managing guest user access to your Teams network, as well as the different layers of guest access and the common challenges that accompany a more complicated Microsoft 365 infrastructure.

You will learn:

  • Who should be allowed to be invited as a guest?
  • What type of guests should be able to access files in SharePoint and OneDrive?
  • How should guests be offboarded?
  • How should you determine who has access to sensitive information in your environment?

Sponsored by:

Office 365 Coexistence for Mergers & Acquisitions: Don’t Panic! Make it SimpleLive Webinar on Tuesday, November 16, 2021 @ 1 pm ET

In this session, Microsoft MVPs Steve Goodman and Mike Weaver, and tenant migration expert Rich Dean, will cover the four most common steps toward Office 365 coexistence and explain the simplest route to project success.

  • Directory Sync/GAL Sync – How to prepare for access and awareness
  • Calendar Sharing – How to retrieve a user’s shared calendar, or a room’s free time
  • Email Routing – How to guarantee email is routed to the active mailbox before and after migration
  • Domain Sharing – How to accommodate both original and new SMTP domains at every stage

Aimed at IT Admins, Infrastructure Engineers and Project Managers, this session outlines both technical and project management considerations – giving you a great head start when faced with a tenant migration.the different layers of guest access and the common challenges that accompany a more complicated Microsoft 365 infrastructure.

Sponsored by: