Coming Soon: GET:IT Endpoint Management 1-Day Conference on September 28th at 9:30 AM ET Coming Soon: GET:IT Endpoint Management 1-Day Conference on September 28th at 9:30 AM ET
Cloud Computing

EU Demands Sweeping Changes to Google Search

EU Demands Sweeping Changes to Google Search
Margrethe Vestager

Regulators from the European Commission are requiring Google to make sweeping changes to its Search service due to ongoing violations of EU antitrust laws. The Commission is also prepared to levy fines against Google that would be high enough to deter the search giant’s illegal behavior going forward.

Google was alerted to these demands in April, but the EC has still not publicly issued its full charge sheet, presumably because it is prepared to let Google settle the case by meeting its demands. But according to several reports, including one in The Wall Street Journal, the EU’s demands go well beyond the abandoned settlement Google almost wrestled from the previous EC administration.

Put simply, Google has been found to be violating EU antitrust laws by abusing its monopoly power in Internet search to hobble competitors and harm consumers, many of whom use Google as their gateway to the Internet. Google has over 90 percent usage share in most of the EU.

“[Our] preliminary conclusion [is] that Google’s practice of positioning and displaying more favorably, in its general search result pages, its own comparison shopping service compared to competing comparison shipping services constitutes an abuse by Google in the relevant markets for general search services,” a redacted version of the EU charge sheet notes.

Sponsored Content

Say Goodbye to Traditional PC Lifecycle Management

Traditional IT tools, including Microsoft SCCM, Ghost Solution Suite, and KACE, often require considerable custom configurations by T3 technicians (an expensive and often elusive IT resource) to enable management of a hybrid onsite + remote workforce. In many cases, even with the best resources, organizations are finding that these on-premise tools simply cannot support remote endpoints consistently and reliably due to infrastructure limitations.

According to the charge sheet, Google has abused its market power in 12 European countries dating back to at least 2008. It does so by artificially manipulating search results to point consumers towards Google services for so-called vertical searches related to shopping and travel instead of more useful or popular competing services. Google’s oversight of the Internet is so vast that it has a deeper understanding of what people are searching for, so it can build or buy new businesses to compete in emerging digital markets it earmarks as both popular and lucrative. And in doing so, Google unlawfully hinders competition and limits consumer choice.

Last year, Google proposed a solution: rather than promote its own services over those of the competition, it would instead place competing services next to Google’s services in the search results. The previous EC administration, led by Joaquin Almunia, agreed to these terms so that Mr. Almunia could claim a final success before leaving his post. But the complaints about this lackluster settlement from EU politicians, competitors, and consumer watchdogs was so vocal, that Mr. Almunia had to back down. And his successor, Margrethe Vestager has pledged to hold Google accountable for its actions.

Vestagar filed formal charges against Google in April. These charges are related only to shopping comparison services, but the EC is still investigating Google’s business practices related to travel and local services, and other vertical searches.

“Based on the facts described in this statement of objections, Google committed the infringement intentionally or, at the very least, negligently,” the EC complaint notes.

Still, Vestagar says that Google could simply do the right thing and put this all behind them. “We will have an open mind to hear what Google will come back with, which means it could go different ways and a settlement is of course also a possibility,” she said in April.

Google has repeatedly denied that it has done anything wrong, and in an incredulous blog posted titled The Search for Harm, it argued that it is always one click away from irrelevance. This is the same type of argument Microsoft used in its antitrust battles from 10-15 years ago, but it took the combined might of the US and EU governments to halt the software giant’s abusive behavior towards competitors. And today, Microsoft competes in markets in which it no longer artificially commands an unfair advantage. Tellingly, things aren’t going so well.

My expectation, as before, is that Google will settle with the EC while admitting no wrong-doing. And in doing so will agree to some behavioral changes that will soften its stance towards competing services. If there is a lesson to be learned from Microsoft’s antitrust woes—and there is—it’s that belligerently defying the laws of the countries in which you do business is not a good strategy.

And there is some evidence of such an outcome.

In his first public interview earlier this month, new Google UK boss Matt Brittin admitted that Google had made mistakes.

“As far as Europe is concerned, we get it,” he said. “We understand that people here are not the same in their attitudes to everything as people in America … We just didn’t have the people on the ground to be able to have some of those conversations as we grew.”

Related Topics:


Don't have a login but want to join the conversation? Sign up for a Petri Account

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Paul Thurrott is an award-winning technology journalist and blogger with over 20 years of industry experience and the author of over 25 books. He is the News Director for the Petri IT Knowledgebase, the major domo at, and the co-host of three tech podcasts: Windows Weekly with Leo Laporte and Mary Jo Foley, What the Tech with Andrew Zarian, and First Ring Daily with Brad Sams. He was formerly the senior technology analyst at Windows IT Pro and the creator of the SuperSite for Windows.

Live on Tuesday, September 28th, at 9:30 AM ET!

GET-IT: EndPoint Management 1-Day Virtual Conference

The management of endpoints is complicated and the risks associated with having unsecured devices roaming outside the firewall are quickly becoming a targeted vector for malicious users. In this Petri one-day virtual conference, we will be diving deep into how you can improve the way you manage your endpoints and learn from industry experts and MVPs about best practices, available tools to streamline your operations, and what's coming soon with Windows 11.


Sponsored By

Live Webinar: Active Directory Security: What Needs Immediate Priority!Live on Tuesday, October 12th at 1 PM ET

Attacks on Active Directory are at an all-time high. Companies that are not taking heed are being punished, both monetarily and with loss of production.

In this webinar, you will learn:

  • How to prioritize vulnerability management
  • What attackers are leveraging to breach organizations
  • Where Active Directory security needs immediate attention
  • Overall strategy to secure your environment and keep it secured

Sponsored by: